GNU Mailman Coding Style Guide

Copyright (C) 2002-2017 Barry A. Warsaw

Python coding style guide for GNU Mailman Core

This document contains a style guide for Python programming, as used in GNU Mailman Core. PEP 8 is the basis for this style guide so its recommendations should be followed except for the differences outlined here. Core is a Python 3 application, so this document assumes the use of Python 3.

Much of the style guide is enforced by the command tox -e qa.

  • When creating new modules, start with the GNU Mailman Python template as an example.

  • Public module-global names should be exported in the __all__ but use the @public decorator from the public package to do this for all classes and functions.

  • Imports are always put at the top of the file, just after any module comments and docstrings, and before module globals and constants.

    Imports should be grouped, with the order being:

    1. non-from imports, grouped from shortest module name to longest module name, with ties being broken by alphabetical order.
    2. from-imports grouped alphabetically.

    Put a single blank line between the non-from import and the from-imports.

  • Right hanging comments are discouraged, in favor of preceding comments. E.g. bad:

    foo = baz(bar)  # This has a side-effect of fooing the bar.


    # This has a side-effect of fooing the bar.
    foo = blarzigop(bar)

    Comments should always be complete sentences, with proper capitalization and full stops (periods) at the end. We use two spaces after periods.

  • Put two blank lines between any top level construct or block of code (e.g. after import blocks). Put only one blank line between methods in a class. No blank lines between the class definition and the first method in the class. No blank lines between a class/method and its docstrings.

  • Try to minimize the vertical whitespace in a class or function. If you’re inclined to separate stanzas of code for readability, consider putting a comment in describing what the next stanza’s purpose is. Don’t put useless or obvious comments in just to avoid vertical whitespace though.

  • Unless internal quote characters would mess things up, the general rule is that single quotes should be used for short strings and double quotes for triple-quoted multi-line strings and docstrings. E.g.:

    foo = 'a foo thing'
    warn = "Don't mess things up"
    notice = """Our three chief weapons are:
             - surprise
             - deception
             - an almost fanatical devotion to the pope
  • Write docstrings for modules, functions, classes, and methods. Docstrings can be omitted for special methods (e.g. __init__() or __str__()) where the meaning is obvious.

  • PEP 257 describes good docstrings conventions. Note that most importantly, the """ that ends a multiline docstring should be on a line by itself, e.g.:

    """Return a foobang
    Optional plotz says to frobnicate the bizbaz first.
  • For one liner docstrings, keep the closing """ on the same line.

  • fill-column for docstrings should be 78.

  • When testing the emptiness of sequences, use if len(seq) == 0 instead of relying on the falseness of empty sequences. However, if a variable can be one of several false values, it’s okay to just use if seq, though a preceding comment is usually in order.

  • Always decide whether a class’s methods and instance variables should be public or non-public.

    Single leading underscores are generally preferred for non-public attributes. Use double leading underscores only in classes designed for inheritance to ensure that truly private attributes will never name clash. These should be rare.

    Public attributes should have no leading or trailing underscores unless they conflict with reserved words, in which case, a single trailing underscore is preferable to a leading one, or a corrupted spelling, e.g. class_ rather than klass.